Understanding Stack Effect in Cold-Climate Buildings: Causes, Consequences, and How to Mitigate It
Stack effect, sometimes called chimney effect, is one of the most powerful and misunderstood drivers of uncontrolled air movement in buildings. In cold‑weather regions like Chicago, Minneapolis, Toronto, and Boston, stack effect contributes to comfort complaints, infiltration, energy waste, frozen pipes, and pressure imbalances that can cripple building performance.
This guide provides a clear, expert-level explanation of what causes stack effect and the strategies building owners, engineers, and facility managers can use to mitigate it.
What Is Stack Effect?
Stack effect is the vertical movement of air inside a building caused by temperature-driven density differences between indoor and outdoor air. In cold climates, warm indoor air rises and escapes through openings at the top of the building, pulling in cold air at the bottom. The taller the building and the colder the outdoor temperature, the stronger the pressure differential becomes.
What Causes Stack Effect in Cold Environments?
1. Temperature Differences Between Indoors and Outdoors
When indoor air is significantly warmer than outdoor air, it becomes less dense and rises. Cold climates create extreme deltas, sometimes exceeding 60–80°F, which significantly amplifies stack pressure.
2. Air Leakage Paths
Stack effect requires openings—intentional or accidental—for air to move. Common leakage pathways include:
-
-
- Unsealed elevator shafts
- Electrical risers
- Unbalanced stairwells
- Unsealed wall cavities
- Gaps around doors, windows, and penetrations
-
Even small gaps compound dramatically under high ΔT conditions.
3. Tall Building Geometry
Building height increases the pressure difference from bottom to top. This is why high-rises feel drafty in lobbies on cold days and experience pressurization issues above the neutral pressure plane.
4. Poorly Balanced HVAC Systems
Under-pressurized lobbies, inadequate makeup air, and imbalanced supply/return airflow worsen the pressure gradient created by stack effect.
5. Improperly Sized or Uncontrolled Exhaust Systems
Exhaust fans pulling more air than supply systems can replace amplify negative pressure at the base of the building, intensifying cold infiltration.
Symptoms of Stack Effect in Winter
Common signs include:
-
-
- Cold, windy building lobbies
- Difficulty opening or closing exterior doors
- Excessive infiltration on lower floors
- Overheating on upper floors
- Elevator shaft drafts
- Whistling at window or door frames
- Frozen pipes in perimeter areas
-
Why Stack Effect Is a Problem
Uncontrolled stack effect impacts:
-
-
- Energy Efficiency: Higher heating loads and longer equipment runtimes
- Occupant Comfort: Drafts, temperature swings, and pressure imbalance
- Indoor Air Quality: Polluted or unconditioned air pulled into the building
- System Performance: HVAC systems unable to maintain intended control zones
- Critical Environments: Pressure-sensitive spaces such as labs, hospitals, or data centers become unstable
-
How to Mitigate Stack Effect in Cold-Climate Buildings
1. Seal Air Leakage Pathways
The most impactful mitigation strategy is limiting pathways for vertical airflow.
-
-
- Seal mechanical shafts, risers, chases, and penetrations
- Install properly rated firestopping
- Close abandoned openings in core walls
- Weatherstrip exterior doors and vestibules
-
Air sealing reduces the pressure-driven “stack highway” inside the building.
2. Pressurize Lower Levels Properly
Lobbies and lower floors must be slightly positively pressurized relative to outdoors.
-
-
- Add or right-size makeup air units
- Ensure proper outdoor air settings and controls
- Confirm doors and vestibules are balanced with airflow measurements
-
3. Heating, cooling, and ventilation must operate in proper proportion.
-
-
- Perform full-system Test & Balance (TAB)
- Adjust outside air economizers
- Correct return air imbalances
- Validate fan capacities against design
-
Proper balancing is a critical step in mitigating stack effect.
4. Control Elevator Shafts and Stairwells
These vertical spaces often act as unintended chimneys.
-
-
- Install vestibules or controlled access at stairwells
- Use automatic closing devices
- Ensure elevator shaft pressurization meets design intent
-
Even minor changes can greatly reduce uncontrolled vertical airflow.
5. Optimize Exhaust and Relief Air Systems
Over-exhausted buildings suffer exaggerated negative pressure.
-
- Recommission exhaust systems
- Adjust building relief or demand-control ventilation
- Confirm kitchen and restroom exhaust flows align with supply air
-
6. Upgrade Building Envelope
-
In some buildings, envelope upgrades offer the strongest long-term value.
- Increase insulation levels
- Replace failed seals
- Add air barriers during renovations
7. Use Building Analytics and Continuous Monitoring
Modern monitoring tools detect pressure imbalances before they create complaints.
-
- Integrate airflow sensors and pressure transducers
- Trend building pressures, temperatures, and flows
- Use continuous commissioning to detect drift
This is essential for mission-critical facilities such as laboratories or healthcare environments.
Conclusion: Managing Stack Effect Requires a Holistic Building Approach
Stack effect is a physics-driven challenge that becomes unavoidable in cold climates. But it is manageable with a combination of:
- Air sealing
- Proper HVAC balancing
- Correct pressurization strategies
- Smart envelope and system design
- Continuous monitoring and commissioning
Whether you're troubleshooting complaints or designing for resilience, a proactive approach to stack effect will improve comfort, control, and energy efficiency across the building lifecycle.
